Tag Archive for: mri

Why Surgery should be your Last Resort for Knee Pain

/in /by

Arthroscopic knee surgery is one of the most common surgeries performed – despite research telling us that it’s not nearly as effective as most people are led to believe. Furthermore, the science tells us that people who do undergo arthroscopic knee surgery are more likely to have knee arthritis that advances rapidly – resulting in a total knee replacement that quite possibly could have been avoided.

Arthroscopic knee surgery is a minimally invasive procedure that’s commonly done to help “clean out” your knee joint if you’ve got degenerative arthritis, or to clip out pieces of a torn meniscus that might be irritating your knee.

Sounds pretty simple and harmless – right?

Well… it is until it isn’t. 

The big problem is that arthroscopic knee surgery is actually not necessary for most cases of knee pain. If there is a complication – which exists even with “minimally invasive” procedures – you could end up being worse off than when you went in. Plus – if you never even needed the surgery to begin with – you just put your knee through unnecessary trauma that you’ve got to now heal from. This further delays you from addressing the root cause of your knee pain.

The truth is that most people can get full relief of their knee pain as well as full restoration of knee function without any type of surgery or procedure. This is true for 70-80% of all knee pain cases.

An early research study from 2002 by JB Mosely and colleagues, and published in the New England Journal of Medicine, revealed that placebo surgery for advanced knee arthritis was just as effective as actual arthroscopic surgery. Since then, numerous studies have proven similar results. This means that even if you have a torn meniscus or degenerative arthritis in your knee – you can still get better naturally and with conservative treatment. 

So why then – despite all this research – are surgeons still performing arthroscopic knee surgery at a higher rate than ever?

In some cases it’s just what the surgeon knows, and they haven’t kept up with the research. Other times, it’s due to poor conservative management of knee pain beforehand. If you’ve gotten physical therapy and it wasn’t effective, people are led to believe that the physical therapy “didn’t work”. But more often than not, you just haven’t found the right physical therapist yet – or seen a physical therapy specialist who is an expert in mechanical knee pain. 

And then there’s the elephant in the room…

It’s very common for knee pain to be coming from somewhere other than your knee.

Knee pain can come from your ankle, hip, or back. One study showed that 25% of the time – knee pain is caused by a source in your spine – even when you don’t have any back pain. MRI’s add even more confusion to this. It’s entirely possible to have degenerative changes, a torn meniscus, or advanced arthritis in your knee – and still have your knee pain stemming from a source other than your knee. For example, in a study by Guermazi et al from 2012, they performed MRI’s on 504 people with pain-free knees. They found that 72% of these folks had bone osteophytes – indicating arthritis. And 25% of them had meniscus tears. So it’s important to not jump into knee surgery simply based on MRI findings.

My career has spanned over 2 decades, and I’ve seen many knee surgeries go wrong. Most of the time, it has nothing to do with the procedure itself, but everything to do with an incorrect diagnosis going in. If your knee pain can be resolved conservatively – and you put it through unnecessary trauma (surgery) – there’s a good chance you’re going to have more problems afterwards. If you get knee surgery when your knee problem isn’t even coming from your knee – then you’re definitely going to have problems afterwards.

The moral of this story is to make absolutely certain that 1) your knee problem is really a knee problem and 2) you’ve fully exhausted all conservative therapy options (including specialized physical therapy) before going under the knife.

Dr. Carrie Jose, Physical Therapy Specialist and Mechanical Knee Pain expert, owns CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth and writes for Seacoast Media Group. To get in touch – or request a copy of her Free Guide: 7 Easy Ways to Get Rid of Knee Pain – click here.

Back Pain MRI

Do You Really Need an MRI for That?

/in /by

Possibly the number one question I get from clients on a daily basis is…

“Should I get an MRI for that?”

Hey… I get it… you’ve got pain that won’t go away and you want to see what’s going on inside… why not?

Not so fast!

What if I told you that getting an MRI too soon (or when you don’t even need one) can actually lead you to getting unnecessary procedures, or even surgery! 

Don’t get me wrong… 

MRI’s are an amazing advancement in medical technology that have saved many lives. And if you’ve had trauma – like a major fall or accident – or you’re exhibiting symptoms that we call “red flags” (progressive/serious neurological deficits, bowel and bladder issues, unrelenting/unexplainable pain) –  then you want to get an MRI. But when it comes to musculoskeletal pain (back, neck, knee, hip, shoulder, etc) – again – unless you’ve had a major fall or trauma – you typically DO NOT need an MRI.

Let me explain…

When it comes to musculoskeletal pain – 80% of the time it’s what we call “mechanical” in nature. That means it’s due to the way you are (or aren’t) moving. For example, let’s say you’re suffering from low back pain and terrible sciatica. Most people in this situation want to get an MRI. And it will reveal anything from a bulging disc, to stenosis, to arthritis, to degenerative discs. Whichever one of these “ailments” shows up on your MRI will typically get blamed as the source of your problem. From there – you’ll typically be prescribed some type of procedure (or surgery) to “fix” said ailment.

Sound familiar?

Well… here’s the thing… research has shown over and over that these so-called ailments appear in the MRI’s of just about everyone over the age of 50. In a 2015 study by Brinkjiki et al – they did MRI’s on over 3000 people who had NO back pain. And you know what they found? For people in their 60’s – they found that 70% of them had disc bulges – 88% had disc degeneration – and 50% had facet degeneration (something you often see with arthritis). And as the age groups increased – so did these ailments!  

The meaning of this and other studies like it is profound…

It means that you absolutely can NOT rely on your MRI to diagnose your problem.

It also means that many people are getting procedures on these normally occurring structural ailments when it’s not even the root cause of the problem.

So what IS the root cause of the problem?

 Typically – it’s “mechanical” – meaning your problem has to do with the way you move, bad postural habits learned over the years, muscular and joint imbalances, or “wear and tear” issues. It’s also why we tend to see more mechanical problems show up in people once they hit age 40 and beyond – because these problems take awhile to manifest.

Although the pain you experience may be coming from one of those ailments we spoke about earlier (for example – a bulging disc irritating your nerve route – a meniscus tear irritating your knee when it moves) – the root cause is how your movement habits are irritating the structure. When you fix the movement problem – the structural issue becomes irrelevant – at least 80% of the time.

If you’re confused – I don’t blame you.

Most medical doctors are not trained in what mechanical pain truly is or what it means. They are trained to diagnose problems using images such as Xrays and MRIs. Nothing wrong with that of course – but it can become a problem when you do an MRI too soon – without first ruling out if your pain is due to a mechanical cause.

If you’re currently suffering from back, neck, hip, knee, shoulder, ankle pain, etc… and you’ve been told you need an MRI to “figure out what’s going on” – hold that thought!

Why don’t you first consult with a mechanical pain specialist. There’s an 80% chance your problem will fall into this category. And you can save yourself from unnecessary treatments that might not work.

You can talk to one of our mechanical pain specialists for free by clicking HERE. It’s a completely free, no-obligation appointment that will give you all the information you need to make the best decision for YOUR health – whether that’s working with us or not!

Dr. Carrie Jose is a Physical Therapy Specialist and Mechanical Pain Expert, and owner of CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth, NH. To get in touch – or inquire about getting help – CLICK HERE or call 603-380-7902

orthopedic surgery

Three Science-backed Reasons not to Rely on Imaging for Orthopedic Surgery

/in /by

Approximately 7 million people undergo an orthopedic surgery each year in the United States. Topping this list are elective procedures (meaning they are not life threatening or urgent) such as ACL reconstruction, total hip and knee replacements, arthroscopic surgery (meniscus repairs, shoulder decompression, etc), and spinal fusions.

Now, what if I told you that of the top 10 elective orthopedic surgeries performed, only one (carpal tunnel syndrome) has real evidence to support that surgery will have a better outcome than conservative care. A recent study published by scientists in the UK hospital system and National Health service reviewed thousands of published studies in an effort to find out if orthopedic surgery was truly better than conservative care or placebo procedures. They found that sadly, thousands of patients are undergoing invasive procedures every year with known associated risks and complications. All while there was an equal or better alternative.

One of the biggest reasons this happens is because people rely on imaging (X-rays, MRI’s, CT scans) to determine whether or not they need surgery. Don’t get me wrong, this incredible technology has revolutionized the field of medicine and orthopedics. The problems occur when we fail to look at the full picture (no pun intended) and rely on images alone to make important decisions about our musculoskeletal health.

Here are three science-backed reasons not to rely on imaging alone when considering orthopedic surgery:

 

1. Imaging does not always correlate with symptoms

One of the most fundamental reasons why imaging alone should not dictate your decision to get orthopedic surgery is the well-documented lack of correlation between image findings and actual symptoms. 

Studies have shown that 20-25% of all people will show a bulging disc in their spine on MRI. This happens even when they don’t have any back pain. At least 50% of adults over the age of 50 will show torn meniscus or cartilage in their knees and feel completely fine. In 2013, The New England Journal of Medicine published a study that found one-third of participants with no knee pain had “abnormal” results in their imaging. This was while one-half of the participants who actually experienced knee pain had completely clear scans. 

We have to start normalizing what aging actually looks like on a scan. Just because you’ve got a bulging disc, torn cartilage, or even “bone on bone” arthritis – it doesn’t mean you need to rush into the operating room.

2. Risk of Over-diagnosis and Overtreatment

Overdiagnosis refers to the identification of conditions that aren’t actually causing symptoms or harming a patient. The biggest culprits here include spinal stenosis, joint arthritis, and degenerative joint conditions. One notable study from 2017 published in PLUS ONE, a peer-reviewed mega journal, found that at least 20% of arthroscopic knee surgeries were overdiagnosed and subsequently overtreated. How did they now? Because even though their scans showed things like “wear and tear” and torn cartilage, they had no relevant dysfunction or clinical findings. The only thing indicating they needed surgery was the overdiagnosis of normal aging in their knee.

A particularly sad story comes to mind as I write about this. I recall treating a man with spinal stenosis who was told by his doctor he needed steroid injections to calm the inflammation in his back. He had 6 weeks until his injections, and during that time, we were able to decrease his pain by about 80%. Since it’s impossible to reverse or stop spinal stenosis without surgery (because it’s related to wear and tear as you age), I knew that his pain was being caused by other unrelated factors. But following doctor’s orders, he still went through with the injections. Unfortunately, he had a bad reaction to the injections that left him worse off than when he started with me. His over-diagnosis of spinal stenosis led to a cascade of over-treatment and worse pain than when he started. 

3. Non-surgical treatments can be equally effective (if not better)

Orthopedic surgery should really only be considered as a last resort. No matter how routine or “non-invasive” the surgery is, there are still risks of infection and complication, and you want to avoid those at all costs. The problem with conservative treatment is that it takes longer to get to the same (or better) result. And let’s face it, we live in a quick fix world and rarely have patience for this, especially when you’ve got a scan that seems to say otherwise.

Study after study shows that arthroscopic knee surgery (in particular) has the same or better results when treated conservatively (physical therapy and exercise). In fact, when you get arthroscopic surgery on your knee, it increases the likelihood you’ll need a total knee replacement. With back surgery, we know that in the first year or two, your pain will be better or gone. But by year 2-3, if your symptoms haven’t crept back in yet, you’ll feel just as good as your peers who forewent surgery. But after year three, your back pain symptoms tend to return, and you’ll often feel worse than your friends who decided to take the conservative approach from the get-go.

The research continues to support that 70-80% of all musculoskeletal pain is mechanical in nature. Mechanical problems have to do with movement dysfunction and lifestyle/postural habits. They don’t show up in a scan, and they are best treated conservatively. When you see something on an image, it’s better to assume it’s irrelevant and that you fall into the 70-80%. This will protect you from being overdiagnosed and help you avoid potentially unnecessary procedures and surgery. Pay attention to your pain, symptoms, and overall function – they tell a much better story than your images.

Are you local to Portsmouth, NH?

Consider seeing one of my Specialists – they’re experts in mechanical pain. In a free Discovery Visit you can tell us everything that’s been going on with you, and determine for yourself if we’re the best people to help you. It’s a no-obligation appointment that will give you all the information you need to make the BEST decision for YOUR health. Whether that’s working with us or not!

CLICK HERE to request a Free Discovery Visit.

Dr. Carrie Jose, Physical Therapist and Pilates expert, owns CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth and writes for Seacoast Media Group. To get in touch, email her at [email protected].

knee pain source

When Knee Pain Doesn’t Go Away – Consider your lower back.

/in , , /by

One of the most important things to get right when it comes to successfully resolving knee pain is to correctly identify the knee pain source.

Is your knee pain actually due to a problem in your knee? Or is the root cause of your knee pain coming from somewhere else in your body?

Rosedale, et al published a study in 2020 that revealed 43% of all isolated extremity pain was coming from the spine. What that means is that you could have nagging knee pain, and no back pain at all, and your knee pain is the result of a lower back problem. I’m not going to get into the technicalities of how this happens. Generally speaking, it’s a mechanical problem in your lower back that causes irritation to nerves or structures that impact your knee – and only your knee.

But how do you know for sure?

One of the biggest clues you’ve missed the root source of your knee pain is that it doesn’t go away after trying everything that “should” help it. Perhaps you’ve tried ice, heat, pain medication, foam rolling, strengthening, and stretching. Even physical therapy – but no matter what – your knee pain just won’t go away. It might get better for a short period, but it always comes back. If the lower back is not considered at this point, then it’s typically when knee doctors get involved. This is great if you’ve actually got a knee problem.

Knee pain that doesn’t respond to conservative treatment should be looked at further. But if your knee pain is a symptom of a problem in your lower back, and it’s missed, you risk having an unnecessary knee procedure or surgery that will only cause you more problems later.

Here’s a quick story about someone this happened to…

I spoke to a client the other day – we’ll call him “David”. He had surgery on his knee to clean out some cartilage and wear and tear from arthritis. They recommended this surgery because he had “failed” regular physical therapy treatment. Nothing else seemed to be resolving his knee pain. It was supposed to be a “quick recovery” and take his pain away because they assumed all his problems were due to arthritis. Well, three months later, Davids knee felt (and functioned) worse than pre-surgery. Now he had back pain to go along with it. To fix the new pain he was having they were recommending even more knee surgery. And now they wanted to do an MRI of his back.

How does something like this happen?

The biggest culprit is over-reliance on imaging to form a diagnosis and treatment plan. Leading you to have the wrong idea of your knee pain source.

If you’re over 50, and you get an X-ray or MRI taken of your knees, there is a 60 to 80% chance they’ll find arthritis and/or meniscus (cartilage) tears. And this will be whether you have knee pain or not. That’s because these are normal changes that occur as you age.

So if you’ve got knee pain, and your doctor wants to do some imaging, there is a very good chance they’ll find one or more of these changes in your knee. They might just blame your knee pain on it without looking at anything else. That’s exactly what happened to David. They blamed knee arthritis for his knee problem when it was actually coming from his lower back.

How do I know?

Luckily for David, he refused the second knee surgery. He went to a mechanical pain expert for diagnosis and treatment, and in 2 months both his knee and back pain were gone.

Do you have knee pain that won’t resolve with typical knee pain treatment? You must consider that it could be coming from your lower back before you undergo any kind of surgery or procedure.

If your knee pain seems to come on slowly or out of nowhere, if you have trouble pinpointing exactly where the pain is, if it moves around and changes from day to day, or if it runs up or down your leg – there is a good chance your knee pain is a symptom of a mechanical problem in your lower back and you should get it looked at.

Sciatica

Suffering from Sciatica? The Do’s and Dont’s

/in , /by

Four out of five people will experience a debilitating back pain and Sciatica episode at one point during their lives. Sometimes this looks like severe back pain that lasts a few days and eventually goes away on its own.

But for some – especially those that have experienced more than one debilitating back pain episode over the course of their lifetime – they experience searing pain down their leg that may or may not persist over a period of time.

When you experience back pain followed by radiating leg pain – this is known as “sciatica”.

Sometimes the pain will only go to your knee, or be a dull ache in the side of your hip and leg. But other times it can manifest all the way down to your foot and be accompanied by numbness, tingling and a loss of strength.

The good news is that there is plenty you can do on your own to help yourself recover from sciatica naturally. But there’s just as much you can do – unknowingly – to make your situation worse.

Here are some Do’s and Don’ts when it comes to sciatica.

The Dont’s:

1. Avoid resting in bed or on the couch.

While it may feel better in the moment – lying in bed or on the couch will ultimately aggravate your sciatica. Sciatica is caused by pinching or irritation of the nerves in your lower back. When you lie in a slouched posture (such as in bed or on the couch) you will put unwanted pressure on these nerves, thus aggravating your symptoms.

The trickiest part about this is that you typically won’t notice the aggravation when you’re resting. You’ll notice it after the fact when you stand up or try to move around, and mistakenly assume the movement is what’s aggravating you instead of the relaxed posture you were just in.

2. Avoid child’s pose and stretching forward.

This is another big misconception about sciatica because it tends to feel really good when you’re “in the moment” and stretching your back forward. Not always, but often, sciatica is caused by a bulging or herniated disc that is pinching your nerve.

The position of bending forward does temporarily relieve pressure on your nerves – which is why it feels good at first – but it doesn’t last.

Stretching forward also opens up the space between your vertebrae. This can influence the protrusion (bulging) of your disc. If you allow your disc bulge to protrude more onto that nerve – your nerve will become more angry and aggravated – as will your sciatica.

3. Don’t let your MRI decide treatment.

As I mentioned in our first two examples, sciatica often involves bulging discs and irritated nerves. And an MRI will typically confirm this. But here’s the thing – tons of people out there have bulging discs showing up on their MRI’s and no symptoms at all.

What matters is whether or not your bulging disc is interacting negatively with your nerve – and that is typically influenced by poor movement strategies.In other words, if you learn how to move better, you can actually make your bulging disc inconsequential and your sciatica will dissipate.

So you should never let your MRI, alone, determine your treatment protocol when you’re suffering from sciatica. What’s more important is how your sciatica symptoms behave during movement. Research has shown this to be more reliable than imaging alone because it tells us in real time what’s happening to your nerves.

The Do’s:

1. Keep moving.

While it may seem counterintuitive to move when you’ve got pain running down your leg – it’s one of the best things you can do.

Try to stand and walk upright as much as you can and pay close attention to what happens in your leg. If the symptoms in your leg start to subside, then you’ll know that your body is enjoying that particular movement and that it’s helping your sciatica.

But here’s the catch – make sure the relief lasts. Lasting relief (vs temporary) is what we’re looking for and it tells us if the movement you’re doing is a good thing for your sciatica.

2. Watch your Posture.

This may seem trivial – but maintaining good posture is critical when you’re suffering from sciatica. Remember that sciatica typically involves a pinched or irritated nerve – and irritated nerves are highly sensitive to postural changes in your lower back (especially slouched postures).

Whether you’re standing, sitting, or lying down – be sure to maintain a small curve in your lower back to minimize your slouch. This helps to keep pressure off your discs and already aggravated nerves.

3. Talk to a Movement Specialist.

While it’s entirely possible to rid yourself of debilitating sciatica without pain pills, procedures, or surgery, you’ll find it easier to do so under the guidance of a movement specialist who specializes in understanding back pain and sciatica.

Yes – you can get an MRI and go see a surgeon – but they aren’t movement specialists. They are surgical specialists. In order to get rid of your sciatica the natural way (with corrective movement strategies) – you need to work with someone who’s an expert in this.

Have you been dealing with back pain or sciatica? Or do you know someone who is?

If you”re local Portsmouth, NH, and you want help NOW for your back pain – Request a Free Discovery Session from one of my specialists. They’ll tell you if we can help and get you set up on a treatment plan right away!

Dr. Carrie Jose, Physical Therapist and Pilates expert, owns CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth and writes for Seacoast Media Group. To request a free copy of her guide to back pain CLICK HERE or to get in touch, email her at [email protected].

Back Surgery

Back Surgery: Why it fails and do you need it

/in , /by

Approximately 500,000 Americans undergo back surgery to relieve their pain every year, and according to the Agency for Healthcare Research and Quality (AHTQ), this costs approximately $11 billion annually.

But what if I told you that only 5% of people undergoing back surgery actually need it – and worse – for many folks the pain ends up coming back. The American Society of Anesthesiologists estimates that 20-40% of back surgeries fail. If you’ve had repeated back surgery your risk of failure increases. Failed back surgery is so common that it’s gotten its own name – “Failed Back Surgery Syndrome” – which occurs when you experience continued pain in your neck, back, or limbs following any spine surgery meant to reduce pain.

So why then do we continue spending so much money on back surgery when the majority of people don’t actually need it – and when half the surgeries fail?

Back pain can be excruciating, debilitating, and have a significant impact on your quality of life and happiness.

If you’re in this situation, and told by a well-respected surgeon that surgery is your best option of taking your pain away and getting you back to living your life again, odds are good you will take that opportunity. And most of the time – surgery does take your pain away – initially that is.

But what surgeons don’t tell you is that your pain has a high likelihood of returning.

If you’ve had one “successful surgery” – you assume the next will go the same. But as mentioned above – the more back surgeries you have – the more likely they are to fail – and the vicious cycle begins.

So when should you get back surgery?

If you’ve had an accident or trauma that has resulted in major damage to your spine – you need surgery.

If you have urgent compromise to one of your spinal nerves you also need surgery. But let me preface “urgent”.

Your symptoms will be progressive and severe.

Signs might include problems with your bowel and bladder, sudden and worsening foot drop (loss of strength and ability to lift your foot and toes), walking will be difficult and progressively worsen, and nothing will take your pain away – medication and rest will barely touch your symptoms.

These cases are rare – but do require surgery to quickly decompress your nerve before permanent damage ensues.

But 70-80% of the time, back pain is what we call non-specific or mechanical.

And surgery is not recommended – and rarely works for this type or back pain.

Mechanical back pain can be acute and last for a few days, or can be chronic and come and go. You might have nerve pain with numbness and shooting pain down your leg, but it won’t be urgent like the situation described previously. The pain you feel is typically caused by irritation to soft tissue structures, discs, muscles, and joints. But the root cause of this irritation is from something different – and that is what we need to care about.

It’s why 50% of back surgeries fail.

Let me explain…

When you get an MRI to see “what’s causing” your back pain – it will typically show some form of bulging disc, degenerative discs, or lumbar stenosis. You will likely be told that these findings are what’s causing compression and irritation to your nerves.

They might try injections and medication first, but when that doesn’t work, they’ll recommend surgery. But here’s the catch. These findings show up in 60-80% of all MRI’s when you’re over the age of 50. But not everyone with these “abnormalities” has back pain.

In other words, you can have two people of the same age, with equal-looking MRI’s, and one will have pain while the other doesn’t.

How does that happen?

What research has shown over the years is that what shows up in your images rarely correlates with what’s causing your back pain.It’s why so many back surgeries fail – because we are messing with “abnormal” findings that are in fact – quite normal for your age. So if the structures aren’t the problem – then what is?

Most back pain comes from poor movement habits and lifestyle.

Over time, repeated, unbalanced movements will exacerbate or cause irritation to these structures that are considered “findings”. But you can’t fix your back problem by only addressing where the symptoms are.

You have to address the root cause. This is typically some combination of restoring full and free mobility in your spinal joints and balancing out flexibility and strength. When you move correctly – these structures are no longer bothered – and neither is your back.

I know what you’re thinking – this sounds way too simple and perhaps you’ve already tried physical therapy or something similar and it didn’t work. Sadly, not everyone understands – or even agrees – with the concept of mechanical back pain in the way I’ve just explained it.

But trust me, when you find someone who does, you’ll be amazed at how easy it is to fix your own back. You can then keep the pain gone – without ever having to see the inside an operating room.

Back surgery can be costly – both to your bank account and mental well being.

That’s a lot of money to risk when there’s only a 50% chance of the surgery working. There’s an even better chance that your pain will come back. If there’s a complication of any kind, then you’re looking at more surgeries. This is an almost certain loss in quality of life.

It’s worth it to do your due diligence. Find a movement specialist who understands mechanical back pain and can keep you out of the operating room.

If you’re dealing with back pain now and want to learn more…

We will be talking all about this and more in our upcoming Masterclass for Back Pain & Sciatica Sufferers.

The Masterclass is free – and happening on January 24th from 6-7 pm via zoom. Reserve your seat HERE – spaces are limited – and there’s a limited number of spots left.

Three Ways You’re Getting Back Pain Treatment Wrong

/in , /by

If you’re over the age of 40 and reading this, odds are pretty good that you’ve experienced back pain at least once in your life. In fact, four out of five people are impacted by back pain, and for many, it’s a constant back-and-forth year after year. Keep reading to learn three ways you could be getting back pain treatment wrong.

The first thing you need to understand is that back pain is normal. It’s hard to combat the everyday stressors our modern-day lifestyles impose on our spine. We simply weren’t meant to sit for hours each day or be crouched over electronic devices. Rather than have unrealistic expectations about pain-free lifestyles, we should instead be focusing on ways to naturally manage our own back pain.

Now keep in mind, I make a living off helping people recover from debilitating back pain. But that doesn’t mean I want you to suffer. Here are three ways we’re getting back pain treatment wrong.

1. Quick fixes and passive modalities.

Reliance on quick fixes or passive modalities is how most people attempt to treat their back pain. It’s also the number one reason why back pain returns. A passive modality is something that is done to you vs something you actively do on your own. It’s where you walk in somewhere, lie on a table, and receive some kind of treatment. This could be chiropractic care, massage, acupuncture, or even injections and surgery. You have no active role in the process – it’s completely passive.

Now, I’m not saying there is anything wrong with these treatments. They are great for easing symptoms related to back pain – especially tight, spasmatic muscles. (I have back pain myself and get a massage once per month.) But they shouldn’t be used in isolation. They need to be part of a more comprehensive, movement-based approach to addressing back pain at its source. Plus – you’ll find the relief you get from passive modalities is almost always temporary. And when your pain keeps coming back – it’s a sure sign you’re missing something. Don’t get back pain treatment wrong by relying on passive modalities.

2. Letting MRI’s make the decision.

Traditionally, the medical community diagnoses your back pain with images. If you’ve had back pain for a while, and especially if you’ve already tried some physical therapy, doctors will prescribe an MRI to “see what’s going on” inside your spine. The problem is that what shows up in your MRI doesn’t always correlate with what’s causing your back pain. In fact, 60% of the time, what you see on your MRI has nothing to do with the root source of your problem.

For example, your MRI might show a bulging disc in your spine. Well, did you know that bulging discs are normal and occur naturally as you age? You could have two people with the same bulging disc on their MRI and one will have zero back pain.

Why? Because the root cause of back pain is more complicated than your anatomy. Evidence from research tells us that 70-80% of all back pain is primarily caused by restrictions in your mobility – which is influenced by your habits and the way you move – not by what’s going on structurally in your spine.

So if your doctor lets your MRI make the decision, and recommends surgery to cut out a bulging disc that isn’t even the source of your real back problem, you’ve not only wasted a surgery, but wasted even more time not addressing the real cause of your pain. Letting MRI’s dictate your treatment plan is one of the most overlooked ways we’re getting back pain treatment wrong.

3. The wrong exercises.

One of the biggest problems I see when it comes to treating back pain is non-specific, non-prescriptive, generalized exercises that are designed to make you strong and perhaps even target your core – but it’s before the real problem gets addressed.

Almost 90% of the time, back pain is due to immobility in your spinal joints (vertebrae) that causes irritation of surrounding structures in your spine – such as discs, nerves and ligaments. What we know to be true is that these mobility restrictions can be freed up with very specific movements, in very specific directions, using a very specific frequency during the day.

Once the restriction in your spine is free and you’re moving normally, you can do any exercise of your choosing. It’s at this point that strengthening your core, for example, is beneficial. Because a strong core helps prevent future back pain episodes (but it doesn’t cure a current back pain episode).

To figure out which specific move you need to address your back pain will require help from an expert. But the good news is once you know what movement gets rid of your back pain, you can use it time and again to manage it on your own. But generalized exercises, when done too soon, is another big way we’re getting back pain treatment wrong.

If you’ve been suffering from back pain longer than you should, I hope this information helps you figure out where you might have been steered wrong.

It’s worth getting help from a back pain specialist who emphasizes corrective, prescriptive movement as a means to recovery – vs quick fixes, MRI’s, and generalized exercises.

Want help from one of our specialists? Request a Free Discovery Call HERE to see if you’re a good fit for what we do.

Dr. Carrie Jose, Physical Therapist and Pilates expert, owns CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth and writes for Seacoast Media Group. To request a free copy of her guide to back pain CLICK HERE or visit her website at cjphysicaltherapy.com.

Is running bad for your knees?

Movement is medicine (when prescribed properly)

/1 Comment/in , /by

I have a confession to make. A few months ago I hurt my own back.

Yes, you read that correctly, the back pain expert injured her own back! I preach this ALL the time to my clients, but one of the reasons I’m so passionate about helping people with back problems is because the treatment is not cookie-cutter. But once we find what works for you, physical therapy is so effective and rewarding.

In my case, I was able to use very specific movements to get rid of my back pain, and then start focusing on strengthening exercises to keep it gone. Don’t get me wrong, there were moments when I wanted to call my doctor and ask him for pain pills, and even the idea of an injection crossed my mind once or twice. But because I keep up with the research, I know that pills and injections really don’t work well for long-term results. Aside from the many potential complications and side effects, quick-fix treatments tend to mask your pain and keep you from doing the real work that is necessary to keep the problem from recurring in the future.

At CJPT & Pilates, long-term solutions are the only thing we are interested in. We believe that movement is medicine.

For all musculoskeletal injuries, including back pain, the research shows that movement and exercise really is the best course of treatment in about 80% of all cases. OK, I know what you’re thinking. If it were that easy, why can’t you just go to the gym, to yoga, or follow an exercise video at home to get rid of your own back or knee pain?

It’s because although movement IS medicine, it only works when prescribed for you properly.

Let me explain.

I’m working with a gentleman right now who’s had back pain for over a year. It started after a car accident. He’s tried regular physical therapy, chiropractic, steroid injections and radiofrequency ablation. None of it worked. He feels good when he exercises and moves around, but the pain always comes back.

When he came to see us, the really interesting thing I noticed about his back was when he put himself in certain positions, he would stand up and literally be crooked. His spine would shift to one side, and become very painful and stiff. In the PT-world we call this a lateral shift, and it’s a sign that indicates he likely has a bulging disc. The great thing about a bulging disc is that they tend to respond very well to corrective movements. Once we know what movement “fixes” you, we can prescribe it to you. This gentleman can now make himself straight and get rid of his back pain in under a minute. Of course the goal is to get him to the point where he no longer needs this corrective movement, but for now, it quite literally is his medicine.

I think the reason more people don’t use this approach is because it requires a little bit of work, and you don’t often see the results immediately. When you get an injection, or even take a pill, the pain is gone in a few hours and it will often stay gone for a period of time without you really needing to do much. With movement, you have to stick with it and do it correctly for it to work. And although you can get an immediate reduction in pain from the correctly prescribed movement, it takes several weeks for it to start to stick and produce long-term relief.

But here’s the best part about using movement as medicine — it’s natural, there are no harmful side-effects, and you can do it completely on your own.

If you’ve been suffering in pain for awhile and tired of using pills or quick fixes to manage your pain, sign up for a FREE Discovery Session with us to find out if movement can be your medicine instead! You can also check out our free back pain guide right here.

tight hips

The Big Reason why Back Pain Keeps Coming Back

/in , /by

If you’re reading this and you’re over the age of 40, odds are pretty good that you’ve experienced back pain at some point in your life. The odds are also pretty good that you’ve experienced back pain more than once.

Every few months or maybe once per year – your back “acts up”. You get rid of it – but it ALWAYS comes back.

Sound familiar?

Well… you’re not alone. Four out of five people are impacted by back pain, and for many, it’s a constant back-and-forth year after year.

But why? Why does back pain always seem to come back?

There are essentially two main reasons:

  1. Back pain is primarily addressed with “quick-fixes” and passive modalities
  2. You (or your doctor) let MRIs make the decisions about your treatment

Quick fixes and passive modalities…

This is the most common way people tend to address their back pain. And it’s the number one reason why it always comes back.

What is a passive modality? It’s something that is done TO you. It’s where you walk in somewhere, lay on a table, and you receive some kind of treatment. This could be chiropractic care, massage, craniosacral therapy, acupuncture, even injections and surgery. You have no active role in the process — it’s completely passive.

Now, I’m not saying there is anything wrong with these treatments. They are GREAT for getting rid or your back pain — and quite often quickly. And they are also great for helping you with other problems, such a stress relief. (I LOVE getting my massage once per month!)

But when your back pain keeps coming back, it’s a big sign something is missing. These treatments are only addressing your symptoms – for example – tight muscles, tension in your nerves, stiff or out of place joints. These things are all the result of your back problem – not the cause.

And it’s the number one reason why your back problem keeps coming back – because the root cause – the thing that is causing you to have tight muscles or stiff joints – is never addressed.

When MRI’s make the decision…

Traditionally, the medical community diagnoses your back pain with images. They use X-rays and MRI’s to see what’s going on inside your spine, and from there, they make a determination of what your treatment should be.

This is a big problem, because what shows up in your MRI isn’t always the reason for your pain. For example, your MRI might show a herniated or bulging disc in your spine. Your doctor will immediately blame that for your pain. And depending on how “bad” it looks, they may suggest injections or surgery. But the truth is, another person could have the exact same visual results as you on their MRI and have no back pain at all.

So why is it that one person can have a bulging disc with no back pain, and another person can have a bulging disc with excruciating back pain?

It’s because the root cause of back pain is more complicated than your anatomy. Research has shown time and time again that 80% of all back pain is primarily influenced by your habits and the way you move, not by what’s going on structurally in your spine.

So you can go in and cut out the disc, but if you don’t identify and correct your poor movement habits that led to that bulging disc in the first place — it’s either going to come back or bulge somewhere else. It’s why surgery only has a 50% success rate for helping people keep back pain away for the long-term.

If you’re confused right now – I don’t blame you.

It’s why so many people suffer from back pain!

It’s also why we offer the opportunity for you to come talk to us for FREE if you’re tired of suffering from back pain with no real answers.

Click here to request a FREE Discovery Session with on of my specialists.

You can also download this FREE GUIDE on how taking care of back pain on your own. It was written especially with the recent quarantine in mind – where so many people have been stuck at home and off their routines.

Either way, you should know that if you want your back pain to stop coming back — it IS possible. You just might have the wrong approach and could benefit from some specialist care to finally get you going in the right direction.