Tag Archive for: arthroscopic knee surgery

Knee Pain

Before You Consider Knee Surgery: Read This

/in /by

Before You Consider Knee Surgery – Read This

Arthroscopic knee surgery is one of the most commonly performed orthopedic procedures in the United States, and total knee replacement isn’t far behind. Both procedures are frequently recommended for people suffering from knee pain, especially when imaging shows arthritis, meniscus tears, or other degenerative changes inside the joint.

But here’s what many people don’t realize – the presence of those findings doesn’t automatically mean surgery is necessary. In fact, research over the past two decades has repeatedly shown that many knee surgeries are performed on people who could have improved with conservative treatment like physical therapy and movement-based care.

For people dealing with chronic knee pain in Portsmouth, NH and throughout the Seacoast, understanding your options before committing to surgery is critical.

The Truth About Arthroscopic Knee Surgery

Let’s start with arthroscopic knee surgery.

Arthroscopy is considered minimally invasive. A small camera is inserted into the joint and the surgeon may trim damaged meniscus tissue or “clean up” arthritic debris. Because the incisions are small and recovery is relatively quick, it’s often presented as a simple solution for knee pain.

But research tells a more complicated story.

A landmark study published in the New England Journal of Medicine by Dr. JB Moseley and colleagues compared arthroscopic surgery to placebo surgery in patients with advanced knee arthritis. Some patients received the full procedure – while others only received small incisions without any surgical repair.

The results were surprising. Patients who received the placebo surgery improved just as much as those who had the real operation.

Since that study, numerous others have confirmed similar findings, suggesting that for many cases of degenerative knee pain and arthritis, arthroscopic surgery provides little additional benefit over conservative care like targeted physical therapy, strengthening, and mobility work.

That doesn’t mean arthroscopic surgery never helps. It simply means it’s often used in situations where other treatments could be just as effective.

In some cases, undergoing surgery when it isn’t truly necessary can even accelerate problems inside the knee joint – increasing your likelihood of needing a total knee replacement later on. Ironically, many people choose arthroscopic surgery in hopes of avoiding that major procedure down the road.

When Is Total Knee Replacement Necessary?

Which brings us to total knee replacement surgery – another procedure that has become increasingly common and, in many cases, more avoidable than you might think.

Unlike arthroscopy, knee replacement is a major operation. The damaged joint surfaces are removed and replaced with artificial components designed to restore function and reduce pain.

When performed on the right candidate, knee replacement can be very successful. About 90 percent of patients experience significant improvement, and many implants last 20 years or longer.

However, that doesn’t mean everyone with knee arthritis or chronic knee pain needs one.

Why MRI and X-Ray Findings Can Be Misleading

One of the biggest misconceptions about knee pain is that arthritis on an X-ray automatically explains the symptoms.

What’s not a misconception, however, is that joint degeneration is incredibly common as we age.

Studies show that only about 15 percent of people with evidence of knee osteoarthritis actually experience symptoms. The other 85 percent walk around completely pain free despite having the same findings on imaging.

MRI studies reveal similar patterns.

In one well-known study published in 2012, researchers performed MRI scans on more than 500 people who had no knee pain at all. Seventy-two percent showed signs of arthritis and roughly one quarter had meniscus tears.

In other words – structural changes inside the knee are far more normal than most people realize.

This is why basing a treatment decision solely on imaging can be misleading.

Sometimes Knee Pain Isn’t Actually Coming From the Knee

Over my two decades of treating patients with knee pain, the biggest problems I’ve seen after surgery rarely had anything to do with the procedure itself.

Instead, the issue was an incorrect diagnosis before surgery.

Sometimes the knee wasn’t actually the primary source of pain.

Knee pain can originate from the hip, ankle, or even the lower back. Research has shown that a surprising percentage of people with isolated knee pain actually respond to treatment directed at their spine.

That means someone could have arthritis in their knee and still have their symptoms driven by a problem elsewhere.

If that underlying cause isn’t identified first – surgery may be unnecessary, and it certainly won’t solve your problem.

3 Things to Consider Before Knee Surgery

Before considering any type of knee surgery – whether arthroscopic or a full replacement – there are several important things to evaluate.

1. The severity of your pain

If your discomfort is manageable and you can still participate in most of the activities you enjoy, rushing into surgery may not make sense.

Even successful knee replacements involve risks such as infection, blood clots, or complications related to anesthesia. Full recovery can take six to twelve months.

2. Whether your spine could be involved

If your knee pain fluctuates, appears suddenly, or occurs alongside back discomfort, it is worth having your spine evaluated by someone trained in diagnosing mechanical pain patterns.

In many cases, addressing the spinal issue resolves the knee pain without any treatment directed at the knee itself.

3. How stiff your knee actually is

With truly advanced arthritis, stiffness tends to be constant and progressive.

But if your knee mobility improves with movement, stretching, or specific exercises, the limitation may be mechanical rather than structural.

When that happens, restoring the right movement patterns can dramatically improve symptoms without surgery.

The Bottom Line: Surgery Should Be a Last Resort

To be clear – knee surgery is not always avoidable. For some patients, particularly those with severe arthritis and significant functional limitations, knee replacement can be life changing.

But surgery should almost always be considered a last resort, not the first step.

Before going down that road, it’s essential to make sure your knee pain has been accurately diagnosed and that you have explored all appropriate conservative treatment options.

Arthroscopic surgery and knee replacement may be among the most commonly performed orthopedic procedures in the country, but that does not mean they are always the right solution.

In many cases, the right diagnosis and treatment approach can restore knee function and eliminate pain without ever needing surgery.

Knee Pain Treatment in Portsmouth, NH

Dr. Carrie Jose is a Physical Therapy Specialist and Mechanical Knee Pain expert. She is the owner of CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth, NH, where she helps people across the Seacoast of New Hampshire overcome chronic knee pain and avoid unnecessary surgery through specialized movement-based treatment.

She also hosts educational workshops and classes for people struggling with knee arthritis, meniscus injuries, and persistent knee pain.

To get a free copy of her Guide to Knee Pain or learn about the next Knee Pain Masterclass in Portsmouth, visit cjphysicaltherapy.com or call 603-380-7902.

Holding Knee with Arthritis

Want to Avoid a Total Knee Replacement? Start Here.

/in /by

Every year, around 700–800,000 Americans undergo total knee replacement surgery – and that number continues to climb.

Here in Portsmouth, NH, we see this trend too – but what if many of those surgeries weren’t actually necessary?

It’s true that knee replacements have an excellent success rate, with more than 90% lasting 20 years or more. But here’s something most people don’t realize…

Only 15% of people who show signs of osteoarthritis on X-ray actually have symptoms. That means the majority of folks walking around with “bone-on-bone” arthritis don’t have any pain at all. Meaning, “severe arthritis” showing up on an X-ray isn’t the be-all-end-all diagnosis you thought it was.

So why do so many end up under the knife?

Because structural findings on imaging – like arthritis, bone spurs, or meniscus tears – are often blamed for pain that may actually have another cause. If you want to avoid knee replacement surgery, it’s critical to understand what’s really behind your pain and whether you’ve exhausted all your options first.

Here are three key things to look at before you resign yourself to surgery.

1. Don’t Let an X-ray Decide for You

Too often, people are told they need a knee replacement because their X-ray “looks bad.” But your level of pain and function – not your imaging – should be what drives your decision.

If you can still walk, climb stairs, and do most of your favorite activities with manageable discomfort – why rush into major surgery with months of recovery and potential complications?

Knee replacement can be life-changing for those in severe, unrelenting pain – but if you’re still functioning relatively well, it’s worth holding off. You may find that a targeted approach to movement, strength, mechanics, and healing can relieve your pain and keep you active for years – without surgery.

And if you’ve already tried physical therapy and exercise but still feel limited, regenerative treatments like Shockwave Therapy and EMTT (Extracorporeal Magnetotransduction Therapy) can help bridge the gap. These non-invasive technologies work by stimulating tissue repair, reducing inflammation, and improving circulation – essentially helping your body heal itself. For many people with chronic knee pain or mild arthritis, regenerative therapy has been a game changer – providing relief and better mobility without needles, surgery, or downtime.

In short, before deciding your knees are “too far gone” just because an X-ray told you so – explore whether your body still has the capacity to heal. You might be surprised at how much function and comfort you can restore with the right approach.

2. Check Your Back (Yes, Really)

One of the most overlooked causes of persistent knee pain is your spine.

A study published in the Journal of Manual and Manipulative Therapy found that over 40% of people with isolated limb pain responded to treatment directed at their spine – even when they didn’t think their back was involved. Plus, even without this study, I’ve seen this all too often in real-life practice.

That means your “knee pain” could actually be coming from irritation in your lower back or nerves. If your knee pain comes and goes, varies with position, or you also experience back stiffness or leg tingling – don’t ignore it or assume it’s all in your knee.

Getting evaluated by a Portsmouth, NH mechanical pain specialist who can test whether your pain is spine-related or knee-related can save you from years of ineffective knee treatments…

3. Assess Your Mobility, Not Just Your Arthritis

If your knee is truly arthritic and severely damaged, it will usually feel stiff and restricted all the time. But if your stiffness fluctuates – maybe it loosens up after you stretch, or feels fine one day and tight the next – that’s a big clue your pain could be mechanical – not degenerative.

Sometimes, a small meniscus fold or mechanical joint restriction is the real culprit, and when the joint is moved the right way, the restriction disappears – along with your pain. Unfortunately, this won’t show up on an X-ray or MRI – and many clinicians miss it unless they’re trained in mechanical diagnosis.

Before agreeing to surgery, find out whether your joint motion can be restored naturally. When you regain full, pain-free movement, your knee may not need replacing after all.

The Bottom Line:

Knee replacements absolutely have their place. For some people, they’re the best path to relief and mobility. But far too many people jump to surgery because they were told their X-ray “looked bad” instead of being evaluated properly for the true source of their pain.

If you’re over 40, dealing with nagging knee pain, and want to avoid surgery as long as possible – start by getting your back checked, your movement analyzed, and your regenerative options explored by someone trained in mechanical pain and tissue healing.

You might just find there’s still plenty of life left in your knees – and the added bonus will be you avoiding a major surgery.

Are you local to Portsmouth, NH?

CLICK HERE to request a free discovery visit with one of our specialists in downtown Portsmouth.

Dr. Carrie Jose, Physical Therapist and Mechanical Knee Pain Expert, owns CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth and writes for Seacoast Media Group. To get in touch – or reserve a seat in her upcoming Masterclass on How to End Knee Pain Naturally – CLICK HERE.

Failed Knee Surgery

Knee Surgery Gone Wrong? It’s More Common Than You Think.

/in , /by

Arthroscopic knee surgery is one of the most common surgeries performed. Despite research telling us that it’s not nearly as effective as most people are led to believe.

Science tells us that people who do undergo arthroscopic knee surgery are likely to have knee arthritis that advances rapidly. This results in a total knee replacement that you could avoid.

Arthroscopic knee surgery is a minimally invasive procedure that’s commonly done to help “clean out” your knee joint. It’s done if  you’ve got degenerative arthritis, or to clip out pieces of a torn meniscus that might be irritating your knee.

Sounds pretty simple and harmless – right?

Well… it is until it isn’t.

The big problem is that arthroscopic knee surgery is not necessary for most cases of knee pain.

If there is a complication – which there are many even with “minimally invasive” procedures – you could end up being worse off than when you went in.

Plus – if you never even needed the surgery to begin with – you just put your knee through unnecessary trauma that you’ve got to now heal from. This further delays you from addressing the root cause of your knee pain.

The truth is that most people can get full relief of their knee pain as well as full restoration of knee function without any type of surgery or procedure. This is true for 70% of all knee pain cases.

An early research study from 2002 by JB Moseley and colleagues, and published in the New England Journal of Medicine, revealed that placebo surgery for advanced knee arthritis was just as effective as actual arthroscopic surgery.

Since then, numerous studies have proven similar results. This means that even if you have a torn meniscus or degenerative arthritis in your knee – you can still get better naturally and with conservative treatment.

So why then – despite all this research – are surgeons still performing arthroscopic knee surgery more than ever?

In some cases it’s just what the surgeon knows, and they haven’t kept up with the research. Other times, it’s due to poor conservative management of knee pain. If you’ve gotten physical therapy and it wasn’t effective, people believe that the physical therapy “didn’t work”.

But more often than not, you just haven’t found the right physical therapist yet – someone who understands how to diagnose knee pain properly and get you the customized approach that is required to avoid surgery.

And then there’s the elephant in the room…

It’s very common for knee pain to be coming from somewhere other than your knee. Knee pain can come from your ankle, hip, or back. One study showed that 40% of the time – knee pain is caused by your back – even when you don’t have any back pain.

MRI’s add even more confusion to this. It’s entirely possible to have degenerative changes, a torn meniscus, or advanced arthritis in your knee – and still have your knee pain stemming from a source other than your knee.

Over the course of my 20 year career, I’ve seen many knee surgeries go wrong.

Most of the time, it has nothing to do with the procedure itself. It has everything to do with an incorrect diagnosis going in. Say your knee pain can be resolved conservatively. Then you put it through unnecessary trauma (surgery). There’s a good chance you’re going to have more problems afterwards. You get knee surgery when your knee problem isn’t even coming from your knee. Then you’re definitely going to have problems afterwards.

The moral of this story is to make absolutely certain that:

1) Your knee problem is really a knee problem and

2) You’ve fully exhausted all (quality) conservative therapy options before going under the knife.

Remember that 70% of all knee pain cases do not need surgery.

Science has proven this. Don’t resort to knee surgery unless you’re 100% sure you really need it. Because it can go wrong and when it does – it’s much harder to come back from then if you had avoided it to begin with.

Want help with your pain now? CLICK HERE to talk to one of my specialists for free – you can tell them all about your knee pain and we’ll let you know if we can help. 🙂

Dr. Carrie Jose, Physical Therapist and Pilates expert, owns CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth and writes for Seacoast Media Group. To request a free copy of her Knee Pain Free Report CLICK HERE  or to get in touch, email her at [email protected].

Holding Knee with Arthritis

Three Tips to Protect Your Knees From Arthritis

/in , /by

Knee arthritis is one of the most common forms of osteoarthritis.

Knee arthritis accounts for more than 80% of all osteoarthritis and impacts at least 19% of Americans over the age of 45.

For many, a diagnosis of knee osteoarthritis leads to chronic, debilitating knee pain that stops them from doing all of their favorite activities. Sometimes it’s simply due to the limiting belief that once you have arthritis – you’ve got “bad knees” for life.

Other times it’s because you’ve been told you have “bone on bone” in your knee and there’s nothing you can do – except to scale back on activity so that you don’t make it worse. This line of thinking is flawed and often leads people to unnecessary procedures and surgery. One of the best things you can do to protect your knees from the debilitating effects of arthritis is to keep moving.

Here are three tips to help you protect your knees from arthritis as you age – so that you can keep doing all of your favorite activities and avoid any major procedures or surgery:

1. Strengthen Your Hips and Core

Your knee joint is situated just below your hips and core. And research has shown that when you have poor control of your upper leg muscles – you get more stress through your knee joint.

The strength of your upper leg muscles is very much dependent on your hip and core strength. Your thigh bone – or femur – connects your knee and your pelvis – and your core strength controls your pelvis.

If your pelvis isn’t stable – your femur is going to have a difficult time staying in alignment – which will ultimately have an impact on your knee joint. If you’ve got arthritis in your knees, it’s critical you minimize any added stress to your knee joints.

Strengthening your core and having good hip strength is going to help prevent and minimize the symptoms of arthritis and keep you doing activities you love longer.

2. Keep Your Knees Mobile

Mobility before stability is my mantra.

And I say this for just about every joint in your body. But it’s especially true for your knees. There are joints whose primary function is stability – and there are those whose major function is mobility.

Your knee needs to be mobile.

Its major purpose is to bend all the way so you can squat and pick things up – and it needs to straighten all the way to give you stability when you need it. When either of these motions are lacking – your ligaments and surrounding muscles will suffer.

A lot of folks just “accept” that their knees are stiff – especially if you’ve been told you have arthritis in your knees. The limiting belief is that stiffness is par for the course. But the truth is that if you keep your knees mobile as you age – you can not only maintain the mobility you have but improve what is lacking.

If your knees are stiff – start moving them. The thing to understand about arthritis is that it’s a normal part of aging. Debilitating mobility is not. Even a 10% improvement in your knee mobility – which can happen even if you’ve got arthritis – will result in huge improvements in your knee function.

It can be the difference between a natural solution to knee pain vs undergoing a major surgery like knee replacement.

3. Don’t Stop Your Activities

When people find out they have arthritis – and especially if they’re in pain – they often think that slowing down or stopping activity will help protect their knees.

This couldn’t be farther from the truth.

Study after study – including one from the Center for Disease Control – shows that severe joint pain among adults with arthritis is worse with inactivity. When you remain active, you keep blood flowing, your knee joints mobile, and your muscles strong. These are very important factors in managing your arthritis. Sometimes, the knee pain you feel when you’re doing certain activities has nothing to do with your arthritis. Statistics show that only 15% of patients with evidence of knee osteoarthritis on X-ray even had symptoms.

That means that the other 85% is walking, biking, and running around enjoying their most favorite activities – despite the fact their X-ray showed arthritis too. The point here is to keep doing your activities – whether you’ve got arthritis already or not – it’s one of the best ways to prevent and protect your knee joints as you age.

So – to review…

If you want to optimize your knee health as you age – which you still can even if you’ve been told you have “advanced arthritis” – prioritize your core strength, the mobility of your knees, and stay active.

Focusing on these three things can have a significant impact on how arthritis affects you – and can help you avoid major (often unnecessary) surgery in your future.

Is knee pain keeping you from doing your favorite activities? Are you considering a major procedure or surgery but not sure if you need it?

Join us on Tuesday Oct. 25th from 6-7pm for our Free Masterclass for Knee Pain Sufferers.

Sign up using this link —> Knee Pain Masterclass.

We hope to see you there!

Can’t make it live? All participants will receive a complimentary replay of the class 🙂

Dr. Carrie Jose, Physical Therapist and Pilates expert, owns CJ Physical Therapy & Pilates in Portsmouth and writes for Seacoast Media Group. To request a free copy of her Knee Pain Free Report CLICK HERE  or to get in touch, email her at [email protected].

Holding Knee with Arthritis

Arthroscopic Knee Surgery – Does it Even Work?

/in , , , /by

While researching for my latest article in the Portsmouth Herald, I came across an interesting study titled: “Arthroscopy for degenerative knees – a difficult habit to break.”

The title of this study is telling.

Arthroscopic knee surgery is still one of the most common surgeries performed, despite research telling us that it’s not nearly as effective as most people are led to believe.

Furthermore, studies now indicate that people who get arthroscopic knee surgery are likely to have knee arthritis that advances more rapidly – resulting in a total knee replacement that could have been avoided.

Arthroscopic knee surgery is a minimally invasive procedure that’s commonly done to help “clean out” your knee joint if you’ve got degenerative arthritis, or to clip out pieces of a torn meniscus that might be irritating your knee.

Sounds pretty simple and harmless – right?

But over the years, research has shown that this procedure is really not necessary in most cases.

Most people can get pain relief and restore function in their knees without ever getting surgery.

One of the earliest studies from 2002 by JB Mosely and colleagues, and published in the New England Journal of Medicine, revealed that placebo surgery for advanced knee arthritis was just as effective as actual arthroscopic surgery. Since then, numerous studies have shown similar results. Even if you have a torn meniscus or degenerative arthritis in your knee – you can still get better naturally and with conservative treatment like physical therapy.

Despite all this research, surgeons are still performing these procedures more than ever.

In some cases it’s just what the surgeon knows, and they haven’t kept up with the research. Other times, it’s due to poor conservative management and not giving therapy enough time to work.

In our office, we often see people after they’ve tried regular physical therapy first. Since we have a more specialized approach, and we’re able to spend more time with our clients, we tend to get better results and can help clients avoid surgery all together.

But not all physical therapy clinics are afforded that luxury. In those cases, people are led to believe that the physical therapy “didn’t work,” and they get scheduled for surgery.

But what’s the big deal really?

If outcomes are the same regardless of whether you get surgery or not – why not just get it? It’s quicker, and far more convenient than going to weekly therapy appointments…

But despite the term “minimally invasive,” it’s still surgery.

You will have bleeding, swelling, and recovery time. There is trauma that is caused to the soft tissue in and around your knee that has to heal. There’s also the risk of infection, which comes with a whole set of different complications.

And then of course there’s the elephant in the room that nobody likes to talk about…

I’ve seen many of these arthroscopic surgeries performed that had clients feeling WORSE than before surgery. Because it turns out the procedure wasn’t even necessary. Luckily, we’re still able to rehabilitate them. But it’s completely demoralizing and discouraging for our clients.

In general, despite how small the procedure may seem, you want to avoid surgery whenever possible.

Although small, the risks that can happen with surgery simply aren’t worth it – especially when you can get the same results from natural, conservative treatment.

For some, arthroscopic knee surgery really is necessary. But for most, it can be avoided.

If you’re currently suffering from knee pain and want to learn more about what you can do to avoid surgery and heal your knee pain naturally and on your own – DOWNLOAD our Free Guide: 7 Ways to Get rid of Knee Pain Naturally.